top of page

Judith Carney, Black Rice: The African Origins of Rice Cultivation in the Americas (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2001)

Jed Cogan & Zach Dulman

 

In Black Rice, Judith Carney details the transfer of rice cultivation techniques from West African societies, across the Middle Passage, to the rice-growing regions of the New World. Although technically the commodity that she is highlighting is rice, the real “commodity” is the knowledge systems and farming techniques behind rice cultivation. The West African region where these techniques came from and were developed was incredibly unique. Carney defines this region in a diagram, in which rice was grown from Senegal in the west to Nigeria in the east, and from the southern Ivory Coast to Mali in the north (39). The landscape across this vast swath of land varied greatly, and thus required a mastery of the environment by the indigenous population. Carney refers to this when she writes, “West Africans plant rice in a complex system of production, which occurs in distinct environments along a landscape gradient” (55). This “landscape gradient” describes the three main categories of rice production: “tidal floodplains, inland swamps... and rain-fed uplands” (57). This detailed knowledge was widespread, and thus when shipments of slaves across the Atlantic commenced, this knowledge came with those native to the rice-growing regions. The transfer Carney studies was mainly between West Africa and North America, however, Brazil was also a large recipient of West African slaves who brought rice and thus cultivation techniques with them. Most of the methods employed specifically by South Carolina planters were exact replicas of the traditional West African methods. However, over time these methods began to be “hybridized” and became part-African, part-European mixes.


One example of this hybridization is the evolution of sluice gates. These gates are used to control

Black Rice 1.heic

Diola woman hoeing rice field, Casamance, Senegal

the flow of water, which proves especially useful in the case of inland swamps to control flooding. Initially in South Carolina, “the plug trunk served as the initial device for water control” (96), which is exactly the method used in West Africa. As time passed, “the original plug trunk gave way to a modified form” that “bears the imprint of both African and European technologies for water control” (96). This gate example brilliantly illustrates the transformation of the knowledge systems of rice cultivation in the New World.

​

Black Rice 2.heic

Rice cultivation along a landscape gradient, central Gambia.

 

Part of what made African rice cultivation techniques so unique was its depth and how applicable it was to a wide variety of environments. This is what made these methods so ripe for innovation. This is shown excellently by Carney with how these different methods directly correlated with the evolution and success of the rice economy of South Carolina. When rice farming first began in South Carolina, “upland or rain-fed rice was emphasized” (85). The main reasons were that it was perfectly complementary to the clearing of forests, and the rotation between rice farming and cattle farming on the land was much needed. The cattle farming raised the initial funds to be able to purchase more slaves than were needed for the more labor-intensive methods. Once the manpower was available, planters could “clear swamps and construct the infrastructure necessary for relocating rice cultivation to the higher-yielding inland swamps” (86). This method involved controlled flooding identical to that of the mangrove system found in West Africa. The final phase was to shift to the highest-yielding method of tidal river floodplains. The construction of this super profitable technique required the building of “floodgates, trunks, canals, banks…” (91), all of which were being built in West Africa. The path from humble beginnings to a profit machine all depended on the adaptability of West African rice cultivation knowledge.

​

Black Rice 3.heic

Children pounding rice with mortar and pestle, South Carolina, c.1920.

A crucial aspect of the commodity chain depicted by Carney is the gendered division of labor in traditional African rice cultivation. From the inception of the rice growing region of Africa, rice was very much a woman’s crop. With the exception of some sub-regions, women were the ones that led the planting and sowing, transplanted the seedlings, and most importantly led the milling process with the mortar and pestle. They also were the ones with most of the technical knowledge behind cultivation, and thus were the best suited to know which regions needed which cultivation methods. Men were mostly involved with the more laborious activities such as turning over the soil. Interestingly enough, slavery worked to dismantle this gendered divide that was at the core of the African rice knowledge system. Because the milling process was so tedious and time-consuming, it was in the planters’ best interest to force the men to participate as well in order to increase efficiency. Overall, Black Rice does a fantastic job with tracing the flow of rice cultivation knowledge from West Africa to the New World and showing how integral this commodity was to the birth of the American rice economy.

bottom of page