top of page

Common Destiny: Atlantic Cod and Conservation

Arthur Hamilton

Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) is the “dominant predatory fish” in most regions of the North Atlantic.[1] Humans have been catching and eating this hearty fish, the average Atlantic Cod is 1.5 meters in length and has a mass of 75 kilograms, on both sides of the Atlantic since prehistoric times.[2] The Mi’kmaq and Malecite of what is now Maine, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia were more reliant on fish, including cod, for nourishment than any subsequent European settlers, and Norwegian Vikings were catching cod on their early voyages to Greenland and Newfoundland in the twelfth century.[3] Indigenous Americans harvested fish from the ocean with the use of birchbark canoes, traveling along the coast and to nearby islands.[4] For the Mi’kmaq, fish was “inextricable from the place” of harvesting, and the consumption of cod and other fish would take place in the vicinity of its catching.[5] For Europeans, the cod trade became a transnational and transcultural maritime industry.

​

Anchor 2
Cod 1.png

The range of atlantic cod. Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations.

​

By the 1400s, western European fish merchants were aware of techniques developed by Vikings in the North Sea, including the on shore air drying of cod. Air-dried cod requires first the salting of the cod (the cod trade was always dependent on a supply of salt), followed by the drying of the cod on the shore. To this aim, fisherman may either create simple wood structures to hang the cod or place the cod on rocks to dry.[6] Dried cod may keep for up to twelve months, allowing for a much more extensive trade of the fish. The Catholic church dictated the consumption of fish on “all Fridays and Saturdays, the six weeks of lent, and the vigils of important festivals such as Christmas eve,” and cod from the North Sea, the Norwegian Sea, and the western approaches of Ireland was sold in Europe’s fish markets to meet religious demand.[7] While the earliest people to fish for cod in Europe were Scandinavian, the cod trade grew to include merchants and fisherman from Brittany, the Basque Country, the west country of England, Portugal, and Italy.[8] As fishing of cod does not require nearby settlement, fisherman from the Basque country may fish for cod south of Iceland as easily as a fisherman from Bristol.

 

The natural living area of Atlantic Cod stretches from the Russian arctic to the coasts of New England, and, in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, European cod fishermen pressed further west in search of new fishing areas.[9] The cod trade became a breeding ground for a generation of European explorers. Christopher Columbus, John Cabot, and Gaspar Corte Real likely all worked in the cod trade before their American explorations, and Bristol fish merchants “may have” made trips to the Grand Banks off the coast of Newfoundland “as early as 1480.”[10] However, it was not until John Cabot’s voyage in search of a Northwest passage in 1497 that Europeans discovered the marine wealth off the coast of Newfoundland.[11]

 

Undersea banks, areas of a raised sea bed, are home to high levels marine life activity and have served as the primary fishing areas for the cod trade in Europe and America.[12] The Grand Banks off the coast of Newfoundland and the Georges Bank off the coast of New England are comparable to European banks such as the Dogger Bank in the North Sea and the Porcupine Bank west of Ireland.[13] Sebastian Cabot wrote of the Grand Bank’s while on sailing with his father. The sea “abounds in fishes, and those very large, [seals], and salmon … but, above all, there is a great abundance of those fishes which we call bacualos [cod].”[14] Colonial competition quickly began as Basque, Portuguese, English, and French fishermen began sailing from Europe to fish for cod in the northwest Atlantic.

​

European Northwest Atlantic cod fishing quickly integrated into the pre-existing cod market. The earliest concrete evidence of a cod fishery in Newfoundland was developed by English fishermen 1531.[15] In the sixteenth century, cod merchants developed a three cornered trade wherein vessels would leave Europe with salt and supplies, catch cod in the Grand Banks or Georges Banks, sell the cod in Catholic southern Europe in return for salt, before either returning to the northwest Atlantic or bringing Mediterranean goods to northern Europe.[16] Following the development of the sugar islands in the Caribbean in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, lower quality cod was be sold in the Caribbean in return for sugar before selling that sugar in Europe.[17] In the sugar islands the cod served as one of the main food supplies for the enslaved population. The Atlantic cod trade was regularly interrupted by international conflicts in the sixteenth century. The destruction of the Spanish Armada in 1588, for instance, displaced much of the Portuguese and Basque presence in the Grand Banks.[18] In the seventeenth century, as major European settlement began in New England and New France, fishermen based in those colonies, some of whom had previously worked in the cod trade in Europe, began to compete with European fishermen in the Grand Banks.[19]
​

Anchor 3
Anchor 4
Anchor 5
Anchor 6
Cod 2.jpg

Map drawn by John Thornton in 1698 showing the Grand Banks, Virgin Rocks, and details of major English fishing harbours in the late 1600s. George Rose, Cod: The Ecological History of North Atlantic Fisheries.

 

The Atlantic Cod trade saw the development of a disposition among fishermen and fish merchants that may be described as proto-conservationist. Early modern and medieval people were capable of impacting the ecosystems around them. In 1289, King Phillip IV of France declared that “every river and waterside of our realm, large and small, yields nothing due to the evil of the fishers and the devices of [their] contriving.” This depletion of river fish precipitated a general shift towards fish from the sea, such as cod, in the European diet.[20] In 1285, 1389, and 1393 England banned the use of nets in catching salmon during the summer months, for fear of salmon stock depletion.[21] While river fish were the primary concerns of European fish conservation, New Englanders feared overfishing sea fish like cod may endanger the livelihood of the colony. In 1639 the Plymouth colony banned the use of cod or bass as fertilizer.[22] In 1660, the Commissioners of the United Colonies of New England wrote:

​

"[We] consider that fish [mackarel] is the most staple commoditie in this countrey and might bee much more benficiall then yet it hath bine if wisly managed; they doe therefore Recommend vnto the Courts of the seurall Jurisdictions that they prohibite fishing for Mackarell vntil the fifteenth day of July yearly that soe fish many increase and bee continued."[23]

​

This proto-conservationist impulse was not driven by a sense of responsibility to nature or the Earth, but instead it resulted from a long-term economic calculation. The depletion or elimination of fish populations may have a catastrophic impact on fishermen, fish merchants, and the region as a whole, and the appeal of proto-conservationism was, therefore, one of self-preservation. Awareness of conservation issues did not always lead to effective action by merchants or governments. Even with the rise of a conservation-driven conservationist movement in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries cod stocks decreased steadily to the point that, with the “cod almost gone,” there is no longer a cod industry in the Grand Banks.[24]

Herman Moll's illustration showing the catching, curing, and drying of cod in Newfoundland in 1720. John Carter Brown Library, Brown University.

Cod 3.jpg
Anchor 7
Anchor 8
Anchor 9

​

Notes

​

[1] George A. Rose, Cod: The Ecological History of the North Atlantic Fisheries. St. Johns, NL:

Breakwater Books, 2007, 67

[2] Ibid.

[3] Bolster, W. Jeffrey. The Mortal Sea: Fishing the Atlantic in the Age of Sail. Cambridge, MA:

Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2014., 50

[4] Rose, Cod 170-171

[5] Ibid.

[6] Bolster, The Mortal Sea 25

[7] Ibid. 27

[8] Rose, Cod 178

[9] Ibid. 180

[10] Ibid 179

[11] Ibid. 180

[12] Ibid. 45

[13] "Banks." Biomes of the World. Accessed May 07, 2021.

https://php.radford.edu/~swoodwar/biomes/?page_id=828.

[14] Rose, Cod 181

[15] Rose, Cod 185

[16] Harold Adams Innis. The Cod Fisheries. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 1940. 50

[17] Ibid. 79

[18] Ibid. 32

[19] Ibid. 133

[20] Bolster, The Mortal Sea 28

[21] Ibid. 29

[22] Ibid. 58

[23] Ibid. 59

[24] Rose, Cod 13

​

Bibliography

​

  • "Banks." Biomes of the World. Accessed May 07, 2021. (https://php.radford.edu/~swoodwar/biomes/?page_id=828.)

  • Bolster, W. Jeffrey. The Mortal Sea: Fishing the Atlantic in the Age of Sail. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2014.

  • Innis, Harold Adams. The Cod Fisheries. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 1940.

  • Kurlansky, Mark. Cod: A Biography of the Fish That Changed the World. New York: Penguin Books, 1998.

  • Pope, Peter Edward. Fish into Wine the Newfoundland Plantation in the Seventeenth Century. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2004.

  • Rose, George A. Cod: The Ecological History of the North Atlantic Fisheries. St. Johns, NL: Breakwater Books, 2007.

Anchor 1
bottom of page